Browse Bay Shore, NY Waterfront Homes for Sale

Living on the waterfront in Bay Shore, NY, offers a perfect blend of coastal charm and convenience. Nestled along the Great South Bay, this Long Island community is known for its scenic views, boating culture, and easy access to Fire Island. Whether you’re looking for a peaceful retreat or an active lifestyle on the water, Bay Shore’s shoreline neighborhoods provide a range of options. Many homes feature private docks, allowing residents to enjoy fishing, kayaking, and sailing right from their backyard. The combination of natural beauty and modern amenities makes Bay Shore, NY, waterfront homes for sale highly desirable.

The most sought-after waterfront areas in Bay Shore include the homes along Awixa Creek, Orowoc Creek, and Penataquit Creek. These neighborhoods offer a mix of historic charm and contemporary designs, with properties boasting panoramic bay views and direct water access. Those looking for a vibrant marina community will appreciate homes near the Bay Shore Yacht Club, where residents can dock their boats and socialize. With its proximity to parks, restaurants, and ferry services to Fire Island, Bay Shore’s waterfront offers a lifestyle that blends relaxation with adventure. If you’re searching for a home by the water, Bay Shore has something for everyone.


Bay Shore, NY Waterfront Real Estate

What is your waterfront home worth?

It would be our pleasure to send you a complimentary Market Value Analysis for your waterfront property, professionally assembled by a leading waterfront specialist in your market.

Bay Shore, NY Waterfront Real Estate Listings

Sort by:

Be the first to receive the newest waterfront listings

Take advantage of our direct access to the leading waterfront specialists in the US and receive new waterfront listings oftentimes before they are published on the open market. Already have in account? Sign in

Bay Shore, NY Waterfront Living

Bay Shore, NY, offers a vibrant waterfront lifestyle with stunning views, easy access to the Great South Bay, and a strong sense of community. Homebuyers searching for waterfront homes in Bay Shore, NY, are drawn to neighborhoods like Brightwaters, Orowoc Creek, and the Penataquit Point area. These communities feature beautiful homes along the water, many with private docks, making them perfect for boating enthusiasts. Residents enjoy peaceful, tree-lined streets while being just a short drive from downtown Bay Shore’s restaurants, shops, and ferry terminals.

Orowoc Creek offers a mix of historic and modern homes with direct water access, making it ideal for those who love fishing and sailing. Meanwhile, Penataquit Point is a sought-after neighborhood with luxury waterfront homes that boast breathtaking bay views. Living in these areas means experiencing the best of coastal living while remaining close to essential amenities. Whether you’re looking for a weekend retreat or a year-round residence, Bay Shore, NY, has a variety of waterfront options to suit different lifestyles.

Popular Shorelines in Bay Shore, NY

Bay Shore, NY, is a vibrant waterfront community known for its scenic beauty and desirable shoreline properties. Located on the South Shore of Long Island, Bay Shore offers a mix of coastal charm and modern convenience. Homebuyers seeking a waterfront lifestyle have several popular shorelines to choose from, each offering unique benefits and breathtaking views of the Great South Bay.

One of the most sought-after waterfront areas in Bay Shore is along Awixa Creek. This peaceful waterway provides a serene setting with direct access to the bay. Homes along the creek range from charming cottages to luxurious estates, many featuring private docks. Residents here enjoy boating, fishing, and stunning sunset views from their backyards. The calm waters make it an ideal location for those who appreciate a relaxed and private waterfront experience.

Another desirable shoreline is along Orowoc Creek, which flows through the heart of Bay Shore. This area is popular among boaters, as it connects directly to the Great South Bay and Fire Island beyond. Many properties along the creek feature deep-water docks, perfect for accommodating larger vessels. The neighborhood is known for its well-maintained homes and strong sense of community, attracting both year-round residents and seasonal visitors.

Southward, along the bayfront, residents enjoy prime waterfront living with spectacular panoramic views. Bay Shore’s bayfront homes provide immediate access to the open water, making them perfect for water sports enthusiasts. The area also benefits from nearby parks and marinas, offering additional outdoor recreational opportunities. Many homes in this region have expansive decks and large windows to take advantage of the stunning coastal scenery.

Penataquit Creek is another notable shoreline where people choose to live. This hidden gem offers a combination of tranquility and convenience, with easy access to local amenities while maintaining a peaceful waterfront setting. Homes along Penataquit Creek often feature well-landscaped properties and private boat slips, making it a great choice for those who want both a suburban feel and a direct connection to the water.

Living along Bay Shore’s waterfront offers more than just scenic views—it provides a lifestyle centered around the water. Many residents take advantage of nearby marinas, yacht clubs, and waterfront restaurants, enhancing the overall experience of living by the shore. Whether it’s kayaking along the creeks, sailing across the bay, or simply enjoying the ocean breeze from a backyard patio, waterfront living in Bay Shore offers a unique blend of relaxation and recreation.

With its diverse shoreline options, Bay Shore continues to attract homebuyers looking for the perfect mix of coastal charm and modern amenities. Each waterfront area has its own character, making it easy to find a spot that fits different lifestyles. Whether seeking a quiet creekside retreat or an open bayfront home with spectacular views, Bay Shore provides plenty of opportunities for those who dream of living by the water.