What is your waterfront home worth?
It would be our pleasure to send you a complimentary Market Value Analysis for your waterfront property, professionally assembled by a leading waterfront specialist in your market.
St. James, NY Waterfront Real Estate Listings
No listings were found matching your search criteria.
Be the first to receive the newest waterfront listings
Take advantage of our direct access to the leading waterfront specialists in the US and receive new waterfront listings oftentimes before they are published on the open market. Already have in account? Sign in
St. James, NY Waterfront Living
Living on the waterfront in St. James, New York means waking up to peaceful views, fresh coastal air, and a lifestyle that blends nature with elegance. This charming Long Island town offers a quiet escape with easy access to the water, making it a favorite for those who love boating, fishing, or simply relaxing by the shore. Some of the most popular waterfront areas include River Road along the Nissequogue River and the scenic shores near Stony Brook Harbor. These neighborhoods offer a mix of privacy, natural beauty, and close-knit community living.
St. James, NY Waterfront Homes for Sale range from classic colonial estates to modern builds with expansive decks and private beach access. Many properties offer direct water frontage, ideal for launching a kayak or enjoying sunset views from your backyard. The area’s calm waters and tree-lined streets make it perfect for families, retirees, and anyone seeking a slower pace without sacrificing comfort. With its blend of coastal charm and upscale living, St. James continues to be one of Long Island’s most desirable waterfront communities. Whether you're looking for a weekend retreat or a full-time residence, the waterfront lifestyle in St. James is both relaxing and rewarding.
Popular Shorelines in St. James, NY
St. James is a quiet Long Island community best known for its leafy streets and historic train station, but it also has small pockets of waterfront living that feel worlds apart from the suburban rhythm. The centerpiece of shoreline life here is the Nissequogue River, which winds through the northern edge of town on its way to Long Island Sound. Along the riverbank, homeowners line roads like Nissequogue River Road and Hillside Avenue, staking out deep lots that back right onto the water. Private docks, boathouses, and gently sloping lawns give these properties a feel more like a country retreat than a typical suburban home.
One of the most popular stretches is Hillside Avenue, where seven waterfront homes currently trade at a median listing price of about $749,000. Many of these large properties sit on more than an acre, with lawns that end at a simple wooden bulkhead or a handful of rocks beside the river. In recent months, these homes have spent an average of just 23 days on the market and often attract multiple offers, underlining their appeal to buyers who want river access without a long drive to the coast.
Just west of Hillside, the river widens into shallow marshlands before narrowing again. Here, small creeks thread through salt grass and reeds, and a handful of custom houses perch on raised pilings. These homes make the most of the panoramic views by installing walls of windows or wraparound decks, so residents can watch egrets, herons, and the occasional osprey gliding overhead. At low tide, boats sit tilted in the mudflats; at high tide, a small skiff can slip right under a homeowner’s private dock.
A short drive south leads to Mill Pond Road, where a historic mill pond once powered local industry. Today the same calm water that turned gears in the 1800s is framed by a mix of mid-century split-level houses and newer colonial styles. Kids splash in inner tubes here in summer, and casual anglers drop lines from the wooden footbridge. Banks are lined with cattails and water lilies, giving the street a postcard-perfect, old-Long Island charm.
Moving away from the river itself, parts of Edgewood Avenue and Lyons Avenue have springs and small tributaries that carve out hidden cove-like patches of shoreline. These are more modest properties—bungalows, ranches, and two-story capes—but they too come with private docks or ladder-style steps down to the water. Neighbors here share informal boat parades in July and swap oyster-fishing tips each fall.
Across all of St. James’s waterfront neighborhoods, people are drawn to the same simple joys: morning coffee on a deck while mist rises off the river, evening paddle-boarding under a pink sunset, or the quiet pull of incoming tides. For buyers, living here means balancing rural peace with practical concerns: shoreline erosion can eat away a bluff over decades, and heavy rains sometimes push the river over its banks.
Before making an offer, visitors often walk each shoreline at different times—sunrise for calm reflections, midday for boat traffic, and stormy days for a true sense of the river’s power. Flood insurance quotes and soil surveys become as important as school district ratings and commute times. But for those who fall in love with St. James’s water’s-edge pockets, the payoff is a front-row seat to one of Long Island’s gentlest waterways—a special way to live where the river meets home.
Browse New York Waterfront Homes by City